AI cracked the Navier–Stokes challenge. What does that mean for physics? - Nature

Email Bluesky Facebook LinkedIn Reddit Whatsapp X Save article View saved research Chaotic vortices the wake of an aeroplane can contribute to aerodynamic drag. Credit: Photo12/UIG/Getty Last week, OpenAI stunned the world by claiming that its most advanced artificial-intelligence model had solved a Millennium Prize Problem: one of just a handful of notoriously tricky mathematical conundrums that each come with a US$1-million prize. The AI solution proved mathematically that there are instances in which the Navier–Stokes equations — famous, nineteenth-century formulae that model how fluids flow — produce a ‘singularity’, predicting physically impossible infinite speeds for gases or liquids. The news has opened up discussions about the blossoming mathematical abilities of AI, whether AI models are soaking up the unpublished work being done by others, who deserves credit and more. But there’s another question, too: what does this mean for the study of fluid flow? The solution posted by OpenAI , which is based in San Francisco, California, explores a situation in which a vortex of fluid stretches out, becoming very long and very thin. George Karniadakis, an applied mathematician at Brown University in Providence, Rhode Island, has calculated that for air, the singularity appears when this vortex becomes around 70 nanometres wide — so thin that its width spans the typical distance that one air molecule travels before hitting another one. It makes sense that this is the point at which the equations break down, Karniadakis says. The Navier–Stokes equations make a simplifying assumption that a fluid is a continuous substance, rather than a collection of chaotic molecules. When there are only a couple of molecules across the sample, that assumption is no longer a good approximation of reality, and the equations fail. Limited scope The Navier–Stokes equations were already known to be insufficient to model reality under certain circumstances. The Millennium Problem focused on fluids that are incompressible, which is a very good description of liquids such as water. For compressible fluids, researchers already knew that the corresponding version of the equations could give rise to singularities, says Charles Fefferman, a Fields Medal-winning mathematician at Princeton University in New Jersey. The equations also don’t work for rarefied gases, so they don’t describe well, for example, what happens when a spacecraft re-enters the upper atmosphere, or when tiny amounts of fluid flow through microscopic channels. One alternative approach is to use the Boltzmann equation, which treats a gas as a collection of individual molecules and models their behaviour statistically, rather than treating a fluid as a continuous substance as the Navier–Stokes equations do. Yu Deng, a mathematician at the University of Chicago in Illinois who won a Fields Medal this year for his work on the Boltzmann equation, told Nature in July that it is unclear what a breakdown of Navier–Stokes could mean for the Boltzmann equation. In principle, those equations could also break down in specific circumstances, too, he said. “Our understanding is very limited.” Another possibility for modelling fluids is rigorous computer simulation of the behaviour of individual molecules. But this is computationally expensive and becomes untenable beyond the microscopic scale. In 2024, for example, researchers used a supercomputer to simulate a record-breaking 155 billion water molecules — which would generally fit into a cube just micrometres in size. Some researchers tackle this computational difficulty by slicing up a problem into sections, using molecular dynamics to model very small scales, the Navier–Stokes equations to model large scales and an intermediate set of equations that lump molecules together to average their behaviour. Karniadakis calls this the ‘triple decker’ approach. Enjoying our latest content? Log in or create an account to continue Access the most recent journalism from Nature's award-winning team Explore the latest features & opinion covering groundbreaking research Access through your institution or Sign in or create an account Continue with Google Continue with ORCiD doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-026-02922-6 Additional reporting by Davide Castelvecchi. Reprints and permissions Related Articles How AI is improving climate forecasts Birds gliding through bubbles reveal aerodynamic trick Rising stars of mathematics awarded prestigious 2026 Fields Medal Mysteries of turbulence unravelled OpenAI claims huge maths breakthrough on a famed ‘Millennium Problem’ Subjects Physics Mathematics and computing Machine learning Latest on: Physics Mathematics and computing Machine learning Who gets credit in the AI era? OpenAI maths bombshell sparks debate News 17 SEP 26 Continuous-wave laser absorption spectroscopy of the thorium-229 nucleus Article 16 SEP 26 Electrically controllable superconducting memory effect in UTe2 Article 16 SEP 26 Chinese companies doubled down on science after US tech restrictions News 18 SEP 26 Who gets credit in the AI era? OpenAI maths bombshell sparks debate News 17 SEP 26 AI companies must work with the research community to protect attribution Editorial 16 SEP 26 How fast are you ageing? Ask AI News 17 SEP 26 How a team of AIs discovered a promising lung-cancer drug News 17 SEP 26 AI companies must work with the research community to protect attribution Editorial 16 SEP 26 Jobs Faculty Search, Vanderbilt University Nashville, Tennessee Vanderbilt University School of Medicine Tenure-Track: Assistant Professor in Marine Biology Assistant Professor - Marine Biology; dynamic marine biologist whose research advances understanding of marine organisms, habitats, & ecosystems Galveston, Texas Texas A&M University - Galveston Associate or Senior Editor, Nature Communications (Polymer Materials) Title: Associate or Senior Editor, Nature Communications (Polymer Materials) Locations: Shanghai, Beijing, Nanjing, New Delhi or Pune (Hybrid) Appl... Shanghai, Beijing, Nanjing, New Delhi or Pune (Hybrid) Springer Nature Ltd Associate or Senior Editor (Sustainable materials chemistry) Title: Associate or Senior Editor, Nature Portfolio (Sustainable Materials Chemistry) Locations: Shanghai, Beijing, Nanjing, New Delhi or Pune (Hyb... Shanghai, Beijing, Nanjing, New Delhi or Pune (Hybrid) Springer Nature Ltd Associate or Senior Editor, Communications Physics Job title: Associate or Senior Editor, Communications Physics Locations: Shanghai, Beijing, Berlin, Heidelberg , Pune (hybrid) Closing date: Sept 3... Shanghai, Beijing, Berlin, Heidelberg , Pune (hybrid) Springer Nature Ltd